Barking Dogs, HDB and Dog Owners


Lots of barking going around. Dogs bark, HDB barks at dog owners, and dog lovers bark back at HDB. People who have irresponsible neighbours who don’t train their dogs in the end have to live with the prospect of having neighbours who have noisy dogs. Was HDB callous in its warning to dog owners? Yes if one is a dog lover, no if one is a victim of noise pollution because of incessant dog barking. It is often a matter of perspective. Dog owners are winning this round as they are barking the loudest, while the ones affected more are silent so far on this controversy. It is often a matter of who can shout the loudest in a political correct way.

Dogs barking loudly for prolonged periods late at night is a public nuisance. Same as playing basketball  in the flat, mahjong, karaoke late at night through the night.  It is not the dog’s fault as they are animals. Any fault if it is a genuine complaint of noisy dogs, is the dog owner who can’t control his animal.  Maybe the solution is that if a dog owner gets frequent complaints about his pet from his neighbours, HDB has the right to step in and force the owner to do something about his nuisance. The dog owner under pressure naturally would see his many neighbours as the nuisance instead.

Let’s not go into the topic of dog owners not cleaning up their dogs’ poop in common and public areas.

HDB suggestion to debark noisy dogs angers animal rights groups

SINGAPORE — A Housing and Development Board (HDB) notice on excessive dog barking that listed the option of surgically debarking dogs as a solution has drawn the ire of animal welfare groups, prompting the agency to take down the notice and apologise.

The notice, which was posted at a HDB block on Ang Mo Kio Avenue 5, was dated Aug 22. In the notice, the housing authority said it had received feedback about dog barking in the middle of the night. “A dog barking excessively can become a nuisance to your neighbours. It could disturb their sleep or affect their work or study,” the HDB said.

It suggested that dog owners who cannot control their pets from barking consider obedience training, using training collars to control them or debarking, which involves the removal of a dog’s vocal cords through surgery.

A photograph of the notice was posted online yesterday by Action for Singapore Dogs (ASD), which described debarking as an “extremely cruel and painful procedure” that can cause constant physical pain.

“A dog also barks when it is in a stressed or anxious mode, and not hearing the dog does not mean the dog is in a stable state of mind,” it said. “Such recommendations should not be publicly put out without due advice from experts as it sets a wrong mindset that such solutions are ethical or safe.”

In a statement, Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) executive director Corinne Fong said debarking usually leaves the animal “with something between a wheeze and a squeak”. “Many veterinarians refuse to do the surgery on ethical grounds. Those who do rarely advertise it,” she said, adding that the procedure is prohibited in the United Kingdom and in some American states.

Added Dr Heng Yee Ling of Mount Pleasant Vets: “We do not do debarking because there are better and more humane ways to control a dog, such as behaviour training.”

The SPCA also objected to the recommendation to use training collars, which work by delivering electric shocks to the dog to correct behaviour.

In a response to media queries, the HDB apologised for causing anxiety to dog owners. “We agree it should have been handled more sensitively, and the notice has since been taken down,” it said.

It also said the notice did not accurately reflect its position. “When residents complain about excessive dog barking, we have always advised and counselled dog owners to manage their pets’ barking and behaviour through obedience training. Debarking should be considered by pet owners only as a last resort when all other measures, especially training, are ineffective, and only if the owner considers it an option,” it said.

ASD president Ricky Yeo said a framework was needed to ensure that a complaint about incessant barking is substantiated. “People also have to understand that changes will not happen overnight. A certain tolerance level should be accepted,” he said. “There needs to be a certain yardstick that everyone lives by. We all live in a very close area, so we have to learn to accommodate and compromise.”

2 responses

  1. Ferocious Fearsome Dogs barking indiscriminately at Neighbors is a sign and symptom that after all these years of Economic Progress from de third to de first world has’t yet achieved the Civiity and Good Neighborliness of Singaporeans,that even Ambassador David Saul Marshall onetime Chief Minister of Singapore declared on his return from Paris ,France ” whatever economics progress we have made mean nothing, our Singaporeans are not yet civil and well mannered evenin this age of plenty !” Or words to that effect ! harking back to an earlier time didn’t founding government of de PAP by building HDB housing with modern flush toilets and lifts ascess to homes an attempt to bring Civiity Clean and Hygienic Living Standards to Singaporeans is it really so difficult to be civil and pleasant to your neighbors ? Instead of using Pets like Dogs for the outpouring of angers and irritations at each other ! How little Singaporeans have achieved inspite of the modern conveniences !Time perhaps to have a a Project like Learn Civility and Good Manners and Consideration ! even in the Freedom of Speech Right Loudnes is not considered such an unfettered right ! Why do people use Dogs & Pets for their emotional outbursts and / or attacks ? Isn’t time to learn conversational speech to each other to settle differences or deliberate anything of value ?

    Gerald c w Heng Sr.
    Metrowest Boston/WashingtonDC USA

    August 29, 2014 at 11:01 am

  2. Pingback: Daily SG: 29 Aug 2014 | The Singapore Daily

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s