Online Dissent, Onstage Dissing and the Streisand Effect


We are familiar with this story structure. Insecure government hates a blog, bans it online via firewalls. The people who actually were indifferent at first before the ban then became curious, causing a surge in online interest in the issue or in the blog, since firewalls are ineffective. The more the government tries to repress the blog, the more popular it becomes ironically.

In Singapore, some sites have been successful in taking advantage of this online quest of the truth silenced by the repressive insecure government. The old Temasek Review was one that periodically said and probably staged that its site was under attack. The “ban” of its site was good publicity and drove more visitors once the site “recovered”, since the layperson thinking was the government attacked or “banned” the site to hide the truth. In the eyes of the politically curious, cynical or clueless, what political views are banned must be good to hear, read or watch.

Square Moon is one such recent example. Never heard of it? Neither did I until the National Arts Council, MDA, Substation, Ministry of Home Affairs, the Necessary Stage, the National Museum and almost everyone else in touch with the play and playwright Wong Souk Yee were all involved in a plot to derail its screening. The play is a hilarious fact-fiction mixed mockumentary of the ISA, ISD and the controversy of the surveillance state. Artists and artistes should have the creative licence to embellish to entertain, and it is insulting that the government thinks that audience, especially those would watch a play, cannot discern.

Under fire, a Vietnamese blogger vows dissent
Thursday, September 13, 2012

HANOI, Vietnam (AP) — Vietnam’s government has vowed to crack down on three dissident blogs, a move that appeared to backfire Thursday as record numbers of people visited the sites and the bloggers pledged to keep up their struggle for freedom of expression.

Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung’s order for police to arrest those responsible for the websites reflects growing unease within the Communist Party over the emergence of blogs and social media accounts that publish dissenting views, independent reporting and whistleblowing. The party doesn’t allow free media, and fears criticism or discussion of its failings on the Internet could lead to social instability and — ultimately — loss of its power.

“Nobody can shut our mouth or stop our freedom of expression,” said a member of the team that administers one of the targeted blogs, Danlambao. “This is our mission. We will continue at any cost.” The blogger chatted over the Internet with The Associated Press on the condition that his name and exact location not be published because of the risk of arrest.

Danlambao, or “Citizens’ Journalism,” is one of the most prominent of several dissident blogs that have sprung up in the last two years.

It has attracted thousands of viewers in recent weeks because of its reporting on suspected power struggles among the ruling elite that it says may have been behind the arrest of a banking tycoon last month. It has speculated that the detention of Nguyen Duc Kien, said to be close to the prime minister’s daughter, was the result of tensions between the premier and the president.

Late Wednesday, the government said Danlambao and two others sites had been “publishing distorted and fabricated articles” against the leadership. It said that Vietnamese state employees were forbidden from visiting the sites.

It is not illegal for Vietnamese to visit the targeted sites, but they are blocked by the government’s firewall. Vietnam blocks many sensitive websites, though the firewall is fairly easy to get around.

“This is a wicked plot of the hostile forces,” a government statement said, adding that the prime minister had ordered police to arrest those associated with the sites.

The statement led to a surge in visitors to the sites as curious Vietnamese wanted to see what they had been publishing, according to the blogs.

The Danlambao blog said it was on course to have more than 500,000 page views Thursday, more than double its normal amount, thanks to what it called the unintended public relations coup handed to it by the government.

One of the other targeted sites, Quanlambao, or the “Officials’ Journalism” blog, said Dung’s threat was meant to lay the legal groundwork for a campaign of arrests against bloggers.

The blogger contacted by The AP said Dung mentioned their site by name to try to scare contributors from contacting it.

“They (the government) are losing control of the independent blogs,” the blogger said. “Not just our one.”

The blogger said Danlambao’s sources of information were other bloggers, journalists who work for state-run media, ordinary citizens and Communist Party members seeking to damage other factions within the party. Some of the material comes from reading between the lines of reports in the state-run media, the blogger said.

“They provide us the bullets and we shoot — because they can’t,” the blogger said.

International watchdog Reporters Without Borders says there are currently at least five journalists and 19 bloggers being held on various charges in Vietnam, part of a gathering government effort to stifle criticism over the last two years even as the country presses ahead with opening its economy to foreign investment. The government labels democracy and free speech activists as terrorists.

Journalists working for foreign news organization are allowed to live in the country but must ask permission to report outside the capital. That is routinely denied if the subject of the story is seen as sensitive or damaging to Vietnam.

3 responses

  1. GCWHeng Sr.

    The Vietnam War was won by the Ho Chi-Ming coalition in great mesaure by the internal Vietnam War Protests in USA that included Lt- John Kerry of the US Navy,now US Senator of Massachusetts,its the essence and core value of a Free Society in pursuant of Freedom of EXpression and Media,there is never a Government Censorship of News and what’s New in the political arena where a Free Marketplace of Ideas prevail.The Constant is and has been always as long as you write and speak your thought civilly engaged your fellow men only Good will come off it in any Democrcatic Government.Vietnam like Singapore are not entirely free societies,singapore being economically well off has and will become much much Freer than in the 1960’s. Singapore will one day be American Media totally free when it has Private Media Channels that are allowed Freedom to express their thoughts and opinions so long as it doesn’t incite crimes of hatred and mayhem ! Asian Societies haven’t learn to jaw jaw jaw as a modus operandi of Government ! Its an everyday occurence in Europe and North America not just around Elections Circle !

    Incidentally the Vietnamese benefited from the internal domestic anti-Vietnam War Protests. It is only now beginning to address the probelms of public criticisms within . What can really go wrong with a Free Market Place of Ideas and Ideals on Governance ????

    Gerald Heng Sr.
    Metrowest Boston,MA. USA
    away in Cape Cod, MA.

    September 13, 2012 at 11:07 pm

  2. Dung4dung

    Dung’s censorship is dung!

    September 13, 2012 at 11:44 pm

  3. Pingback: Daily SG: 18 Sep 2012 | The Singapore Daily

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s